Happy Haiti, tech billionaires! Happy #Haiti, #Pierre Omidyar, #PamOmidyar, #JeffBezos, Larry Page, Sergey Brin, Mike Dell, Larry Ellison, Bill Gates, Paul Allen, Arianna Huffington!
January 14th, 2010
It’s hard
to find words for what
has happened in Haiti — it’s shocking,
horrifying, life-shattering, grotesque, sickening.
Yet those words won’t suffice a week from
now. There won’t be words strong
enough a week from
now.
after the disaster” is the term
used in aid circles to describe the absolutely
catastrophic harm that follows the “light” initial shock
of an earthquake or tsunami or genocidal attack. The disaster
after the disaster is death by starvation, thirst, environmental toxicity,
air- and water-borne disease, gender and ethnic violence, lack of access
to aid that has been commandeered by thugs or corrupt officials.
The epic horrors of the first hours of Hurricane Katrina and
Banda Aceh and Cyclone Nargis were nothing compared
with the death and disease and human
suffering that followed in
their respective
wakes.
Events
like these sicken everyone.
They sicken me ever so much more so because
I’ve been trying to give an idea to the world for a decade now
which would dramatically ameliorate the disasters after the disasters.
You can read about it at www.earthnationlive.org if you like, or watch the
(less detailed) three minute video at the end of this post. It’s about
using the internet to create a worldwide citizen action network
that could be called upon instantaneously to provide
the most important relief there is in a disaster
like the one that’s unfolding in Haiti:
fast relief.
People
whose eyes are filled
with concrete and glass, whose bones
are broken, whose skin is torn open in the presence of raw
sewage — those folks need help in a hurry. It takes time for a government
or a Red Cross or a United Nations to get medicine, food, water,
clothing, and shelter to people in a land where a
disaster was unanticipated and the relief
network is poor or
nonexistent.
As
well-financed and
well-organized as the Red Cross, the UN,
and governments are, they are also huge. And huge moves slow,
even when it’s trying to move fast. Ocean liners need time and miles to
change direction. The relief that saves the greatest number of
lives and alleviates the most suffering comes from another,
faster source. As I write in the synopsis of
the Earth Nation Live
idea,
“In the
early days after the
tsunami struck Thailand in 2004,
the greatest early relief there was provided not
by the UN or the Red Cross but by a man who owned some trucks
in the hills of Thailand — not tractor-trailers, just lorries for hauling melons
and wood and junk. He directed his friends and family members
and employees to load food and water and clothing into
them and simply drive them toward the coastal
areas. This one man saved
thousands of
lives.
“I know
people who have been
working for two decades with the
Karen and Kachin people who inhabit the
forests of northern Thailand and Burma. The border
is porous there because the land is wooded and largely unroaded.
Hours after Cyclone Nargis hit Myanmar, if the network I’m proposing
were in existence, a handful of strategic emails and phone calls would have
immediately had massive amounts of food, water, and medical aid moving
from Bangkok to northern Thailand, to be borne across the border and
down into the Irrawaddy Delta, in individual packages, on millions
of wily, indigenous Karen and Kachin feet — no ships, no planes,
no government interference. With the direct result that
there would be fewer photos like this one existing
(and accumulating) in the
world today.”
worldwide network through music.
A whole heaping buttload of money flows
through music on this planet — it ranks just slightly
behind guns, drugs, and sex on the financial Richter scale.
Among the many things Earth Nation Live would do is buy and place
millions of inexpensive self-powered satellite computer systems and crazy
cheap walkie-talkies for and into the kinds of non-governmental citizen network
hands that — were they in place — would and could save hundreds of thousands
of lives in Haiti now. Save them by getting food and medicine and water where
it most needs to be, most efficiently, most rapidly, with least chance
of hijackings or hoardings. Save them by helping citizens police
themselves when regular law enforcement mechanisms are
utterly overwhelmed. Save them by helping people
find one another, find the hand they need,
find their way out.
But
those lives won’t
be saved, because those networks
aren’t in place. I can’t, so far, get the idea financed —
it requires a really big piece of software up front (like this),
and it would cost maybe $10 or $20 million to build that. I could
pay that back, with generous interest, within six or nine
months, after a first concert: LiveAid raised over
$200 million in one day in 1985. But I can’t
build that piece of software without
some dough.
I’ve been
trying to get it from the
most logical place in the world for
nearly a decade: tech billionaires. People like
Pierre and Pam Omidyar, founders of Ebay, and Jeff Bezos,
founder of Amazon, and Paul Allen and Bill Gates, founders of Microsoft.
Sergey Brin and Larry Page, founders of Google. Michael Dell, founder of Dell
Computer. Larry Ellison, founder of Oracle Software. You’d think of all
the people in the world who would understand the power of the
internet to improve the efficiency of citizen action in disaster
relief and other efforts, people who got crazy fookin’ rich
pimping Pez dispensers and books and computers
and software over the web would
be right up front.
And you’d
think they could spare the
change for a few months. I started appealing
to the Omidyar Network in early 2003. That’s seven years ago,
if my math is right. I’m slightly loony, as you know if you read this
blog regularly, but I was perfectly polite in explaining the idea at a website
they created expressly, they said, to help people help people. They were
going to give their Ebay fortune away, they said. My memory
(a sometimes flawed device) was that their personal
windfall from Ebay was something like
$5.5 billion dollars at
the time.
$20,000,000
out of $5,500,000,000 is,
mathematically, .36%. There’s a decimal
there, it’s a third of a percent, roughly. The interest on
$5,500,000,000 at 5% (a low rate of return for people like tech
billionaires, who have access to the world’s most
productive investment opportunities)
would be $275,000,000.
A year.
So what
I’ve been asking for from
people like the Omidyars, Bezos, Allen,
Page and Brin and Ellison and Gates is, effectively, a stick
of gum to them. An old stick of gum, a lint-covered stick of gum
from the pocket in a rarely-worn rain jacket left in the
trunk of the old Saab that doesn’t get driven
anymore since the billions
came in.
You
wouldn’t believe the
number of times I’ve asked, the number
of ways I’ve asked, how thoroughly I’ve articulated
the idea, on all their web forms, in hundreds of emails and letters
and strippercakes and candygrams which I know were received. If I printed
out all the letters and emails, I could wallpaper my house, and yours, and
their very large and numerous vacation homes. Aside from interactions
with assistants to the assistant’s assistant, well, lessee, Pierre Omidyar
personally acknowledged my existence once. Jeff Bezos had an
underling email to say he wouldn’t consider any idea I sent him.
Allen, Gates, Google, Nathan Myhrvold, Lord Larry Ellison,
dozens ‘pon dozens of others, absolutely nothing, though
often after startled expressions of ”Awesome idea!”
from someone sifting their email or snail mail.
Doesn’t matter if I go through channels, like
Google.org or the 10 to the 100th Project
or a friend on the Omidyar’s or
someone else’s board. Nada
after the first ”Awesome!”
from employees who
ought to
know.
Vexing,
a little, on most days.
Things take time, after all.
But mad, mad, mad
frustrating on
post-disaster
days like
this.
“Perhaps
you’re not a gifted communicator,
BW!”, you might say. Perhaps. I tend to look at
things like the Earth Nation Live website and the little video
at the end of this post and think, “Sums it up pretty well — big idea,
cool idea, demonstrably workable, right up their tech billionaire alley.”
I know how to find email addresses, phone numbers, all kinds of channels,
and tell if they’re working or not. (One of the things about billionaires is that
they kinda sorta gotta read their email, or have someone read it, because they
occasionally get threatened or extorted. And the ones who set up websites
to save the world are, er, doubly obligated.) My dealings with the largest
publishing houses and the richest movie studios in the world
suggest I’m not completely inept with words.
Maybe even pictures.
But this
lovely lickle idea,
born of a hundred conversations
between my dearly departed daughter and myself,
born of thousands of hours of unpaid thought, languishes.
Without a doubt, it would reduce the number of photos
of dogs eating human babies, and human adult
corpses, mounting today in the world.
I find those photos so
tiring:
Nonetheless,
here we are. Waking up to
another day on Earth where dogs
will be eating babies (those pictures even
I won’t publish), and children will
be slowing down, slowing
down, until they are
not children but
corpses.
Just
not the babies
of billionaires. Just not
the children of tech wizards.
Their kids are high and dry,
sitting on billions in cash.
Cash is comfort, they
say. Cash is
king.
donate (a-t) earthnationlive (d-o-t) org








[...] tragic scene in Haiti: chaos in the aftermath [...]
[...] I’ve asked again and again. I’ll pay it back with [...]
OMG.
how sad..
:(((((((((((((
[...] the condensed version, read this on “the [...]
[...] but not about sharing a little money for a few months. [...]
[...] 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 [...]
[...] 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 [...]
[...] 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 [...]
[...] doesn’t can take a spin through Chapters 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 [...]